Saturday, August 03, 2002

One thing I've always queried in the debate on public spending in the UK is the belief that in Europe they spend much more. It is true that as a proportion of GDP, other EU governments seem to spend far more. I can't off hand remember the figurs but I think the UK government spends about 42% of GDP and somewhere like Germany it is more like 50% of GDP.

Yet surely what matters is what that money is spent on. The other EU countries have much higher pensions contribuitions as show in this (free) Economist article . Reading off the chart, Italy spends 13% of GDP on pensions, France and Germany 12%, and Spain 9%. The UK, with its poverty pension level, spends 5.5%.

If then you work out what proportion of GDP the government spends excluding pensions, the UK must spend a similar or in some cases more than those countries (although obviously one shold take account of payments that the UK has to make to pensioners to keep them from poverty such as income support).