Friday, September 10, 2004

A nation of millionaires

You'll recall this week's story based on a report by accountancy firm Smith & Williamson, that said the average higher-rate taxpayer pays 50% of his/her income in tax. As I pointed out, the analysis was laughable, as it included seven years' housing stamp duty in one year.

I said at that time that there were two conclusions one could draw

1. Smith & Williamson knew that this was wrong, but they didn't care, because they wanted to score political points.
2. Smith & Williamson genuinely didn't understand how averages work.

It appears there is a 3rd suggestion. A correspondent writes:

Smith and Williamson may have correctly calculated the stamp duty over seven years, but perhaps they believe the average higher rate taxpayer pays some £1.3m for their property.


This indeed might be the case. If so I expect a press release from Smith & Williamson, and an editorial in The Telegprah lauding this government for creating a class of over 3m millionaires. Truly an economic miracle.