The Lancet
I've discussed the Lancet article endlessly on other sites, and, as we know from the comments below, this is the site that discusses things other sites don't, so I'm not going to post on it here.Luckily I don't need to, as Daniel Davies has the goods on the critiques (most of which are so bad you can only marvel at them) over at Crooked Timber.
He misses out one devestating line of attack however. It's what I call the 'I can feel it in my bones' critique. This is where the blogger (and it's always a blogger) can 'feel it in their bones' that the report 'can't be right'. I would link to some obvious examples, but 'I can feel it in my bones' that it would be pointless.